US Department of Energy was Wrong, Rely on Value Line
Volume I, Issue 47 | email: info@outperform.biz
BASEBUILDING STAGE WHOUDL BE ENDING BETWEEN NOW AND EARLY DECEMBER, FOLLOWED BY A MOVE TO THE UPSIDE. BEWARE OF NEGATIVE ECONOMIC NEWS AND FORECASTS. INDICATORS WILL SHOW US THE WAY.
Equity markets have been in a trading range since Oct. 10. The markets declined into the range of the Oct. 10 lows on Oct. 27 and again on Nov. 13 as interbank lending rates (Libor or TED Spread), the Volatility Index and the number of new lows have improved. For example, the number of shares making new lows on the New York Stock Exchange were 2,910 on Oct. 10, 1,125 on Oct. 27, and 776 on Nov. 13. The Dow Jones Utilities Index (DJU), which usually leads the markets, has also been in a steady rising trend since Oct. 10. When the considers these factors together with the extent of the decline, the high level of pessimism, a 10-year high in insider buyer, and extreme undervaluation, this trading range should be resolved to the upside in the days or weeks ahead. This will likely happen at the same time that the US dollar and Japanese yen fall as other currencies and commodity prices snap back from very oversold levels. Prices for assets other than cash are not just down, they are distorted. We know they are distorted because the interest rate on well over a $US trillion in one month US Treasury Bills is pretty well zero. The value of cash is too high and every thing else is too low. This will change.
That equity markets could improve flies in the face of almost every bit of information we hear. Last week I presented evidence that most analysts were optimistic at market highs and pessimistic at market lows. Last week there was more evidence of how unreliable some of the best forecasts are. Last month, the US Department of Energy (DOE) forecast that oil prices would average $112 per barrel for 2009. Last Thursday, the analysis and statistics wing of the DOE changed the forecast for 2009 from $112 per barrel to $63.50. It is instance like this that has made me realize that most economic forecasts and analyst opinions are of little predictive value. If an independent group of experts like the US DOE can be so wrong, what can we rely on? I believe that one of the best things to rely on are statistical measurements (such as the Value Line information mentioned last week) and the indicators you see in this update. For example, the short-term trend indicator turned red (predicting a downtrend) for oil on July 17 at $129 per barrel at which time I issued a special update with the headline "Oil is Peaking." It proved to be very accurate. (Please see an up-to-date chart for oil below.) The reason they are reliable is that they measure what is actually going on in the marketplace. When buying peaks, the uptrend is over, no matter how positive things appear to be. When the selling subsides, the downtrend is over, no matter how bleak the news presents things to be or how worried people are. When the short term and then the long term trend charts turn green (positive) it will be a very clear indication that the trend has changed.
Prices for any asset peaks when there is positive news and bottoms when there is negative news. The long-term oscillators indicate that the worst-case scenario has been factored into the current prices of many assets. The major sector that has not turned positive yet is the US financial sector. (See the US Banking Index BKX chart.) These stocks are hovering near the July 15 and October lows and seeming to be holding the markets back. They need to show some strength in order for the markets to turn. I will continue to do my best to keep you informed of any changes, which could now happen at anytime.
Bonds – According to the oscillators, the outlook for US and Canadian bonds is still positive.
Commodities – Gold and oil (and their stocks) are very oversold but have not started an uptrend yet.
Currencies – The US dollar and yen have not weakened enough to indicate a trend change.
This short term trend chart shows the basebuilding of the US markets since Oct. 10. The DJU is providing leadership but the financial sector is not. One of the initial signs that the trend is changing will occur when this indicator turns green for all market indexes.
The Volatility Index is not as high as it was at the market low on Oct. 27. This should turn red to confirm a trend change for all the market averages.
The long term trend chart for the SP 500, TSX and other market averages should turn green to indicate that the shorter term uptrend has longer term potential. That will take time or a major advance.
The long term oscillator for the US Banking Index will turn up to indicate that the stocks in the US financial sector have finished testing the July, October and November lows.
While the US financials are weak, the Dow Jones Utilities Index (DJU) is showing traditional leadership by continuing to rise since the Oct. 10 lows even though other market averages have continued to revisit the lows. This is a good clue that the basebuilding phase should transition to the upside.
The Canadian TSX and other global market averages should turn green when the US markets turn positive too.
The long term oscillators for Canadian and US bonds turned positive in recent weeks and are still in the early stages of an uptrend according to this. Bonds often rise before stocks do.
Precious metal stocks are oversold and poised to rise once the financials get their act together.
Energy stocks also seem like they are poised to rise as soon as the US financials stabilize and turn up.
Gold is oversold but has not turned up yet. Since everything is very oversold, a turn can come at any time.
The chart for oil has been red ever since July 17 when oil was at $129, even during the big spike in September.
The long-term oscillator for the euro vs. yen is oversold and has turned up. There has been improvement but not quite enough to turn the short-term trend indicator green. That will be another important confirmation of a change in the trend for asset prices. It will be over when it is over.









